I was talking to a friend the other day, and he said something that really made me uneasy. What made me uneasy was the seemingly casual demeanor he portrayed in his statement which really solidified how easily and somewhat unthoughtful his words were. And it’s not that I think my friend is a bad person, not at all, but it was just shocking how cheerful I know he is that he could have a belief in life that is so dark and apathetic.
His statement?
Life is meaningless, so what’s the point of living?
Immediately, I had to ask him, why do you think this? And he responded, isn’t it evident? Look at the world, it’s pointless. And I really wanted to know how he got this mindset, and what’s even more strange is that if you look at the way he lives his life, you’d never guess he could say that.
We didn’t have much time to really debate this topic, but he did bring up some points to me that I couldn’t help but think about, and I was thinking, is there a good way to prove a meaning to life? Then I thought this.
The very fact we are able to derive the idea that there is no meaning in life, indeed confirms that there is a meaning to life, though, the meaning weāve interpreted for ourselves, maybe doesnāt justify the suffering. Thus, we ask if there really is a justful meaning, and even conclude there isn’t.
And that might be quite a lot to take in, so let me see if I can break it down in a way that might make more sense.
The best way I can explain meaning in life is actually through music. Iām not going to play you a song or anything, but Iām going to ask you to really think about what Iām going to say, and please try.
Here it is:
Have you ever listened to a song that made you feel something? And maybe you donāt know what you felt, but you know thereĀ wasĀ something, and you know itĀ wasĀ real. When you get this feeling, a lot of times, you donāt know how to describe it with precise words, though, you might be able to loosely illustrate it with scenes of imagery or a short narrative. And thatās really what aĀ goodĀ song does,Ā it tells a story.
But hereās the thing. A critic of music might say, why even bother listening to a song? Itās going to end anyways. And the funny thing is, almost all of us can recognize thatās not a very good representation of what music is, and the purpose of music is not just to listen to it knowing itās going to end, but to invoke the emotions we might not be able to feel without it, and maybe even to overcome problems we might not have been able to overcome in the absence of it.
And thatās what music does.
It puts us in a state of being where we transcend reality, and puts us in a place that we donāt know where we are exactly. The distinction of where we are physically, and where we are metaphysically becomes warped in a way where we enter a place thatās, in a sense, not real. And then the song ends, and youāre back, and you realize you never went anywhere, but itĀ feelsĀ like you did. Youāre able to describe where you were, ā in a garden of flowersā āin the woodsā āback when I was 7 sitting in my roomā, and youāre able to describe as if you really were there. This is why people often sayĀ āI got lost in the music.ā
How does this relate to the meaning of life?
Well, just like music, weāll do things in life things weāre not fully engaged with i.e. weāre bored. And there are songs that we may find boring, but we donāt dismiss music as a whole, so we shouldnāt dismiss life because weāre bored of it. Once again, there are songs that might make us feel weak and afraid; it exposes us. But still, we donāt dismiss music then, and we shouldnāt dismiss life just because we feel vulnerable.
And so, you might be saying, well thatās just music, weāre talking about life here. Those two areĀ totallyĀ different. Thatās when Iāll say, no, not really.
And why?
The same feeling you get when youāre listening to a meaningful song, the same sense of timelessness you feel, the same way you canĀ lose yourselfĀ in the face of suffering when listening to that song, this can be achieved by living a meaningful life.
And that really says something.
It says, life is suffering, yes. But we can orientate ourselves in a way that weāre aiming at something so meaningful that the the suffering of life is no longer relevant, or even we can accept that it exists. Itās the same as if weāre listening to a powerful song, how we can only appreciate itās deepness once we accept the level of suffering it took to write it. With the same processes we use to identify a meaningful song, we have the inherent ability to identify when weāre doing something meaningful in our lives. And again, itās something youĀ canāt really explain. You might find someone so engaged in what theyāre doing they say, āMan, Iāve been doing this all day, and I donāt want to stop.ā And itās not only can they can do this for one day,Ā but for the rest of their life.
Iāve heard it described like this. When youāve found something in your life thatās so meaningful that you can look at the suffering of the world, and even in spite of that suffering, not become resentful or cruel, but actually work to make the world a better place, thatās been described as a āBrief habitation with the kingdom of God.āAnd Iām not trying to become religious here, Iām only saying that you will never find anything as useful as that.
So, you ask,Ā Whatās the point of living if life has no meaning?
My response would be this. Itās not that life has no meaning, you just haven’t found the right song.